Help - Search - Member List - Calendar
Full Version: Are domain names under registrar lock lost forever?
WorkTheWeb Forums > Webmaster Resources > Webmaster - General Help
Support our Sponsors!
Justin Sane
I have tried to register domain names that have been for 1-2 years under
"Registrar lock" status, and it appears that these domain names are lost
forever, right?
Unless the ex-owner releases these domain names, no one can register them,
and as long as he doesn't pay, he can't use it either. Is there a way to
release these names (I don't know the name of the owners, they don't
appear on the whois page) ?

--
Thanks,

Justin.
http://www.opera.com/mail/

Steve Sobol
Justin Sane wrote:
QUOTE
I have tried to register domain names that have been for 1-2 years
under  "Registrar lock" status, and it appears that these domain names
are lost  forever, right?

Registrar lock just means the domain can't be transferred out from under
you. If the domain is registered, however, you can't legally take it anyhow.

What's the domain name?

--
JustThe.net - Steve Sobol / [Email Removed] / PGP: 0xE3AE35ED
Coming to you from Southern California's High Desert, where the
temperatures are as high as the gas prices! / 888.480.4NET (4638)

"Life's like an hourglass glued to the table" --Anna Nalick, "Breathe"

Justin Sane
On Sun, 03 Jul 2005 17:41:13 -0300, Steve Sobol <[Email Removed]>
wrote:

QUOTE
Registrar lock just means the domain can't be transferred out from under
you. If the domain is registered, however, you can't legally take it
anyhow.

The domain names used to be registered but have expired for at least one
year.
I guess they're blocked forever :s

--
Thanks,

Justin.
http://www.opera.com/mail/

Viper
Justin Sane wrote:
QUOTE
On Sun, 03 Jul 2005 17:41:13 -0300, Steve Sobol <[Email Removed]
wrote:

Registrar lock just means the domain can't be transferred out from
under you. If the domain is registered, however, you can't legally
take it anyhow.

The domain names used to be registered but have expired for at least
one year.
I guess they're blocked forever :s

Some registers will keep a domain when it expires. I had one tell me if I
didnt renew it with them that they would kep it after it went through
redeemption, etc...

Steve Sobol
Justin Sane wrote:

QUOTE
The domain names used to be registered but have expired for at least
one  year.
I guess they're blocked forever :s

Ok, now please answer: What's the domain name you're wondering about? (or names)


--
JustThe.net - Steve Sobol / [Email Removed] / PGP: 0xE3AE35ED
Coming to you from Southern California's High Desert, where the
temperatures are as high as the gas prices! / 888.480.4NET (4638)

"Life's like an hourglass glued to the table" --Anna Nalick, "Breathe"

Justin Sane
On Sun, 03 Jul 2005 18:58:14 -0300, Steve Sobol <[Email Removed]>
wrote:

QUOTE
Ok, now please answer: What's the domain name you're wondering about?
(or names)

Steve, I'll give you the example of a domain name that I have in my domain
name list, that I don't want anymore, that is expired, that I don't want,
but that is no available to public: gentoodesktop.com. It has the status
of "Registrar Lock". If I select it and select "Delete", I get an alert
saying that I'll have to pay a fee if I want to release the domain name.
So... I just leave the domain name in my list of expired domain names. No
one can register it, I don't want it either.


--
Thanks,

Justin.
http://www.opera.com/mail/

Justin Sane
On Sun, 03 Jul 2005 18:34:48 -0300, Viper <[Email Removed]> wrote:

QUOTE
Some registers will keep a domain when it expires. I had one tell me if I
didnt renew it with them that they would kep it after it went through
redeemption, etc...

I think you're right. This is sad.


--
Thanks,

Justin.
http://www.opera.com/mail/

Steve Sobol
Justin Sane wrote:
QUOTE
On Sun, 03 Jul 2005 18:58:14 -0300, Steve Sobol <[Email Removed]
wrote:

Ok, now please answer: What's the domain name you're wondering about?
(or names)


Steve, I'll give you the example of a domain name that I have in my
domain  name list, that I don't want anymore, that is expired, that I
don't want,  but that is no available to public: gentoodesktop.com. It
has the status  of "Registrar Lock". If I select it and select "Delete",
I get an alert  saying that I'll have to pay a fee if I want to release
the domain name.  So... I just leave the domain name in my list of
expired domain names. No  one can register it, I don't want it either.

Well, I can explain what is happening.

The domain expired on 5/28 of this year.

Starting a couple years ago, expired domains aren't deleted out of the root
nameservers immediately. This was meant to prevent domain speculators from
jumping on them the minute the domains expired. Unfortunately, the domain
now goes into a redemption period for a month or so where you must pay a
relatively high amount of money to get the domain back. It's meant to
discourage domain brokers, but IMHO it screws honest people more than the
scammers.

Give it a few more weeks and it should be deleted.


--
JustThe.net - Steve Sobol / [Email Removed] / PGP: 0xE3AE35ED
Coming to you from Southern California's High Desert, where the
temperatures are as high as the gas prices! / 888.480.4NET (4638)

"Life's like an hourglass glued to the table" --Anna Nalick, "Breathe"

Steve Sobol
Justin Sane wrote:
QUOTE
On Sun, 03 Jul 2005 18:34:48 -0300, Viper <[Email Removed]> wrote:

Some registers will keep a domain when it expires. I had one tell me if I
didnt renew it with them that they would kep it after it went through
redeemption, etc...


I think you're right. This is sad.

I think if you trust Viper about anything, you're being quite foolish. He
does not know what he's talking about.

As I explained in the other post I just made in this thread, the domain is
probably in redemption status. But OnlineNIC doesn't show the status.
Registrar lock normally shows as REGISTRAR-LOCK or something similar, but if
it expired and the grace period was over it would show REDEMPTION status, as
previously described.

OnlineNIC's whois really ought to show the status.

http://www.whois.sc/gentoodesktop.com


--
JustThe.net - Steve Sobol / [Email Removed] / PGP: 0xE3AE35ED
Coming to you from Southern California's High Desert, where the
temperatures are as high as the gas prices! / 888.480.4NET (4638)

"Life's like an hourglass glued to the table" --Anna Nalick, "Breathe"

Viper
Steve Sobol wrote:
QUOTE
Justin Sane wrote:
On Sun, 03 Jul 2005 18:34:48 -0300, Viper <[Email Removed]> wrote:

Some registers will keep a domain when it expires. I had one tell
me if I didnt renew it with them that they would kep it after it
went through redeemption, etc...


I think you're right. This is sad.

I think if you trust Viper about anything, you're being quite
foolish. He does not know what he's talking about.

As I explained in the other post I just made in this thread, the
domain is probably in redemption status. But OnlineNIC doesn't show
the status. Registrar lock normally shows as REGISTRAR-LOCK or
something similar, but if it expired and the grace period was over it
would show REDEMPTION status, as previously described.

If you believe Steve and dont believe me then you are a fool. I had a domain

drop to REDEEMPTION status. I emailed to get the domain back into my account
and renew it. The Register told me they needed $100. I told them I would
wait until it dropped and register it at another Register. They replied back
that I can do that BUT they have the option to KEEP the domain and use it
themselves after the redeemption period was over.

The only reason I got the domain back was because I went to a domain forum
that has 15,000 members and let them know what was said. The head/owner of
the register then posted at that forum and said they changed their rules and
I could have it for the $6.95/yr.

Steve Sobol
Viper wrote:

QUOTE
If you believe Steve and dont believe me then you are a fool. I had a domain
drop to REDEEMPTION status. I emailed to get the domain back into my account
and renew it. The Register told me they needed $100. I told them I would
wait until it dropped and register it at another Register. They replied back
that I can do that BUT they have the option to KEEP the domain and use it
themselves after the redeemption period was over.

That is absolute bullshit, unless they plan on registering it. I'll thank
you to give me some credit for knowing exactly what I'm talking about; I've
been registering domain names since the mid-90s, and have helped many other
people too.

QUOTE
The only reason I got the domain back was because I went to a domain forum
that has 15,000 members and let them know what was said. The head/owner of
the register then posted at that forum and said they changed their rules and
I could have it for the $6.95/yr.

The ONLY way they get to keep it is if they register it when it drops out of
the root nameservers. They don't get to keep unregistered domains... and an
unregistered domain is useless anyhow, as it will not resolve!

Viper, I know you're an idiot, and most of the other people here know you're
an idiot. You don't have to make it blindingly obvious.

--
JustThe.net - Steve Sobol / [Email Removed] / PGP: 0xE3AE35ED
Coming to you from Southern California's High Desert, where the
temperatures are as high as the gas prices! / 888.480.4NET (4638)

"Life's like an hourglass glued to the table" --Anna Nalick, "Breathe"

Viper
Steve Sobol wrote:
QUOTE
Viper wrote:

If you believe Steve and dont believe me then you are a fool. I had
a domain drop to REDEEMPTION status. I emailed to get the domain
back into my account and renew it. The Register told me they needed
$100. I told them I would wait until it dropped and register it at
another Register. They replied back that I can do that BUT they have
the option to KEEP the domain and use it themselves after the
redeemption period was over.

That is absolute bullshit, unless they plan on registering it. I'll
thank you to give me some credit for knowing exactly what I'm talking
about; I've been registering domain names since the mid-90s, and have
helped many other people too.

The only reason I got the domain back was because I went to a domain
forum that has 15,000 members and let them know what was said. The
head/owner of the register then posted at that forum and said they
changed their rules and I could have it for the $6.95/yr.

The ONLY way they get to keep it is if they register it when it drops
out of the root nameservers. They don't get to keep unregistered
domains... and an unregistered domain is useless anyhow, as it will
not resolve!
Viper, I know you're an idiot, and most of the other people here know
you're an idiot. You don't have to make it blindingly obvious.

Who ever said they wasnt going to register it?
BTW I forget the domain but I once seen one that was registered at
NetworkSolutions that was expired for well over 3 years and they had not
dropped it.

So now stop making an ass out of yourself.

Steve Sobol
Viper wrote:

QUOTE
Who ever said they wasnt going to register it?

That's not what you implied, and you know it. Of course if they register it,
it's gone. Of course, if anyone ELSE registers it, it's still gone.

But by pouncing on the domain the day it expires, they're no better than the
slimy domain brokers...

QUOTE
BTW I forget the domain but I once seen one that was registered at
NetworkSolutions that was expired for well over 3 years and they had not
dropped it.

Never seen that... have seen domains stick around for months, but never that
long. Must have been a while ago...

--
JustThe.net - Steve Sobol / [Email Removed] / PGP: 0xE3AE35ED
Coming to you from Southern California's High Desert, where the
temperatures are as high as the gas prices! / 888.480.4NET (4638)

"Life's like an hourglass glued to the table" --Anna Nalick, "Breathe"

Viper
Steve Sobol wrote:
QUOTE
Viper wrote:

Who ever said they wasnt going to register it?

That's not what you implied, and you know it. Of course if they
register it, it's gone. Of course, if anyone ELSE registers it, it's
still gone.
Nah I meant they would register it.


QUOTE
But by pouncing on the domain the day it expires, they're no better
than the slimy domain brokers...


Yep.

QUOTE
BTW I forget the domain but I once seen one that was registered at
NetworkSolutions that was expired for well over 3 years and they had
not dropped it.

Never seen that... have seen domains stick around for months, but
never that long. Must have been a while ago...

It was 6 months to a year ago. I read about it somewhere and did a whois..
sure enough at the time it was expired and was over 3 years expired.

Steve Sobol
Viper wrote:

QUOTE
It was 6 months to a year ago. I read about it somewhere and did a whois..
sure enough at the time it was expired and was over 3 years expired.

Hm. I would have figured it would be before Network Solutions lost their
monopoly on domain registrations. They were incompetent assholes back then,
but there was nowhere else to go.

I don't know how they are now; I dumped 'em a couple years ago.


--
JustThe.net - Steve Sobol / [Email Removed] / PGP: 0xE3AE35ED
Coming to you from Southern California's High Desert, where the
temperatures are as high as the gas prices! / 888.480.4NET (4638)

"Life's like an hourglass glued to the table" --Anna Nalick, "Breathe"

Viper
Steve Sobol wrote:
QUOTE
Viper wrote:

It was 6 months to a year ago. I read about it somewhere and did a
whois.. sure enough at the time it was expired and was over 3 years
expired.

Hm. I would have figured it would be before Network Solutions lost
their monopoly on domain registrations. They were incompetent
assholes back then, but there was nowhere else to go.

I don't know how they are now; I dumped 'em a couple years ago.

Same here.

Trent Jones
"Viper" <[Email Removed]> wrote in message
news:2mLye.8385$4U5.4958@trndny03...
QUOTE
Steve Sobol wrote:
Viper wrote:

It was 6 months to a year ago. I read about it somewhere and did a
whois.. sure enough at the time it was expired and was over 3 years
expired.

Hm. I would have figured it would be before Network Solutions lost
their monopoly on domain registrations. They were incompetent
assholes back then, but there was nowhere else to go.

I don't know how they are now; I dumped 'em a couple years ago.

Same here.

Just as a side note, for a while Netsol was definitely holding on to expired
names (they would not technically expire, so they would never go to
"redemption" status). Why? Because they suck SO BAD and were losing domains
so quickly from drops and transfers to other registrars that in order to
make themselves look better they were holding onto expired names instead of
dropping them.

- SG

Trent Jones
"Steve Sobol" <[Email Removed]> wrote in message
news:da9nd8$vrf$[Email Removed]...
QUOTE
Justin Sane wrote:
Well, I can explain what is happening.

The domain expired on 5/28 of this year.

Starting a couple years ago, expired domains aren't deleted out of the
root nameservers immediately. This was meant to prevent domain speculators
from jumping on them the minute the domains expired. Unfortunately, the
domain now goes into a redemption period for a month or so where you must
pay a relatively high amount of money to get the domain back. It's meant
to discourage domain brokers, but IMHO it screws honest people more than
the scammers.

Give it a few more weeks and it should be deleted.

I think the system works OK. After your name expires, you have 30 days to
change your mind and re-register the name at normal cost. Instead of then
releasing the name, Verisign keeps the name another 30 days just in case you
really really didn't want to lose the name (it is now in "redemption"
status). But, as penalty for being an idiot they charge you a buttload of
money. Believe me, plenty of people wait 40 or 50 days and then say "UHHH,
my name just stopped working???" Yeah, HELLO, did you not notice that a
month and a half ago? So, it's nice that it's harder for people to
accidentally lose their names and if you wait too long I think an "idiot
tax" is appropriate.

- SG

William Tasso
Writing in news:alt.www.webmaster
From the safety of the cafeteria
Trent Jones <[Email Removed]> said:

QUOTE
"Viper" <[Email Removed]> wrote in message
news:2mLye.8385$4U5.4958@trndny03...
Steve Sobol wrote:
Viper wrote:

It was 6 months to a year ago. I read about it somewhere and did a
whois.. sure enough at the time it was expired and was over 3 years
expired.

Hm. I would have figured it would be before Network Solutions lost
their monopoly on domain registrations. They were incompetent
assholes back then, but there was nowhere else to go.

I don't know how they are now; I dumped 'em a couple years ago.

Same here.

Just as a side note, for a while Netsol was definitely holding on to
expired
names (they would not technically expire, so they would never go to
"redemption" status).  Why? Because they suck SO BAD and were losing
domains
so quickly from drops and transfers to other registrars that in order to
make themselves look better they were holding onto expired names instead
of
dropping them.


Sounds like the landlord that prefers to keep buildings empty than rent
them out cheap as the 'potential' income figures can be hiked more easily
than actual revenue.


--
William Tasso

GreyWyvern
On Thu, 07 Jul 2005 04:07:25 -0400, Trent Jones <[Email Removed]> wrote:

QUOTE
So, it's nice that it's harder for people to
accidentally lose their names and if you wait too long I think an "idiot
tax" is appropriate.

Hehe, I'll probably be calling it that from now on ;)

Grey

--
The technical axiom that nothing is impossible sinisterly implies the
pitfall corollary that nothing is ridiculous.
- http://www.greywyvern.com/webslavent?msg=149 - Presto the Puffin!

Steve Sobol
Trent Jones wrote:

QUOTE
I think the system works OK.

If the grace period is now standard, I'd agree. It wasn't standard before.
Every registrar *seemed* to be different.

--
JustThe.net - Steve Sobol / [Email Removed] / PGP: 0xE3AE35ED
Coming to you from Southern California's High Desert, where the
temperatures are as high as the gas prices! / 888.480.4NET (4638)

"Life's like an hourglass glued to the table" --Anna Nalick, "Breathe"


PHP Help | Linux Help | Web Hosting | Reseller Hosting | SSL Hosting
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2006 Invision Power Services, Inc.